close
close

Anatomy of a Murder: The Horrifying Assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson | World news

Anatomy of a Murder: The Horrifying Assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson | World news

Anatomy of a Murder: The Horrific Murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson
In this photo provided by the New York Police Department, UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson is suspected of being killed outside a Manhattan hotel where the health insurer was holding an investor conference, Wednesday, Dec. 4, 2024. (New York Police Department via AP)

Targeted killing UnitedHealthcare general director Brian Thompson captivated the nation not only with its audacious execution, but also with the social tensions it highlights. As the investigation continues, new details are emerging that shed light on the shooter’s methods, potential motives and broader implications for America’s already divisive health care debate.

New details of the investigation

Actions of the shooter before and after the murder
Surveillance footage pieced together the suspect’s movements in the hours before and after the murder. A militant dressed in black tactical uniform and a balaclava was spotted:
La walk near the Hilton hotel: He appeared to be on the phone, walking around the grounds for nearly ten minutes before the attack.
At a nearby Starbucks: The suspect had bought drinks and snacks shortly before the shooting, mingling with morning commuters.
Escape route: After the shooting, the killer fled the scene on a bicycle, using the long trails of Central Park to avoid law enforcement. Investigators believe he may have abandoned his bike and got into a waiting car, although that remains unconfirmed.

Evidence has been recovered

Law enforcement officers found several pieces of physical evidence, including:

  • Ballistics: Shell casings found at the scene had cryptic engravings, potentially indicating personal or ideological motives.
  • Digital Trail: Forensic experts analyze nearby cell towers to track a suspect’s phone activity.
  • Surveillance data: NYPD is reviewing footage from hundreds of cameras in midtown Manhattan, but the suspect’s balaclava and tactical gear make identification difficult.

How the murder happened

United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson

At about 6:45 a.m., Thompson left the Hilton, presumably in preparation for his investor presentation scheduled for later in the morning. Surveillance video shows the gunman calmly approaching from behind, pulling out a silenced firearm and shooting Thompson in the back.
The CEO tried to escape but was pursued by the assailant who continued shooting, hitting him in the chest and leg. Witnesses described the eerie silence of the shots through the silencer. The gunman then fled on a bicycle, disappearing into Central Park within minutes.

“Put it off and put it off”

The attacker fled on an electric bike, leaving behind shell casings and a mobile phone. The words “delay” and “deposit” were written on the skin and in a straight circle, echoing tactics allegedly used by insurers to deny claims, raising suspicions of a motive linked to frustration with the health care system.
The inscriptions slightly resemble the title of the book Delay, denial, defensewhich describes tactics reportedly used by insurers to deny claims. Law enforcement agencies can check to see if this points to a potential motive — dissatisfaction with insurance companies.
“It’s very unusual,” said Joseph Giacalone, a former NYPD sergeant and now a professor at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice. “I’ve never come across anything like this and spent years investigating.”
The shooting comes amid widespread criticism of UnitedHealth, which a Senate report accused of using artificial intelligence tools to deny claims. Public reaction online has been polarizing, with some expressing anger at the denial of treatment, pointing to systemic failures in the US health care system. In social media posts, including from doctors, the shooting is a symbol of public distrust of private insurers.
Thompson, a 20-year veteran of UnitedHealth, ran its insurance unit, which generates $280 billion in annual revenue, making it the largest U.S. health insurer. A graduate of the University of Iowa, Thompson was widely respected in corporate circles but faced backlash over the company’s practices.
The NYPD used drones and a GPS system to locate the suspect. While investigators are looking into the possibility of a motive for the complaint, they remain cautious about whether the evidence could be misleading. Thompson’s death underscores the public’s growing disenchantment with for-profit health care and raises broader questions about corporate accountability and systemic injustice in US health care.

Public and online reaction

Festive tone among critics of the health care system
Online reaction to Thompson’s death was sharply divided. While many sympathized with his family and condemned the act, others saw it as a form of karmic justice, reflecting public outrage at the health care industry.

Popular memes and posts:
A viral TikTok video with the caption: “When you refuse care, karma doesn’t need pre-authorization.”
The meme, shared on X (formerly Twitter), shows a “claims denied” stamp with the text: “Disclaimed: Compassion not covered by this plan.”
These posts illustrate the deep frustration many Americans feel with a system they believe puts profits over people.
Concerns about the normalization of violence
While some activists expressed understanding of the anger, many cautioned against glorifying violence. Critics say such a response risks trivializing a tragic act and could undermine constructive efforts to reform the health care system.

Broader implications: health, justice and society

Health care as a flash point
Thompson’s murder drew attention to the US health care system. As CEO of UnitedHealthcare, Thompson oversaw a company accused of denying treatment, using artificial intelligence to reduce benefits and engaging in anti-competitive practices. These criticisms have sparked calls for universal health care and stricter industry regulations.
Parallels with the Daniel Penney case
The killing also draws comparisons to the Daniel Penney case, where public opinion was similarly polarized over questions of justice and accountability. In both cases, the public debate moved beyond immediate action to encompass broader societal grievances—violence against individuals versus systemic violence caused by policy and practice.
The Road Ahead: What It Means for America
Thompson’s killing has already sparked debate about the future of the US health care system and the limits of public disillusionment. Policymakers and business leaders are likely to face new pressure to address unfairness and abuse in the system.
As the investigation unfolds, one thing becomes clear: Thompson’s death is not just the story of one man’s murder—it is a symbol of a nation grappling with deep-seated inequality and the dangerous consequences of being left unaddressed.